Regarding Troy Tulowitzki, we may not be asking the right question.

Troy Tulowitzki represents the exact kind of player that many teams either can’t or won’t consider. Don’t interpret this as a knock on the player. He’s one of baseball’s best shortstops and would make plenty of teams better. Problem is, the math changes dramatically when his age, injury history and contract are considered.

Here are some numbers:

  • He has approximately $115 million remaining on a contract that runs through the 2020 season. He’ll make $20 million a season between 2015 and 2019. He’s baseball’s 25th-highest player this season. Only one shortstop, Jose Reyes at $22 million, will make more.
  • Among all shortstops, he’s ninth in OPS, 10th in home runs and 13th in OBP. He’s first in doubles and 25th in’s defensive rating system.
  • He has played an average of 93 games the last six seasons and 74 the last four.

So is he worth it? He played just 91 games last season, but was tremendous with a 1.035 OPS. Yes, Coors Field factored into those numbers. He had a 1.246 OPS at home, .811 on the road.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Even if the contract wasn’t there, plenty of baseball people love Andrelton Simmons, Freddy Galvis, Erick Aybar and Jhonny Peralta, perhaps ranking all of them ahead of Tulowitzki. Marcus Semien and Addison Russell are highly regarded young guys. Starlin Castro would be much in demand if the Cubs wanted to move him.

Again, this is no knock on Tulowitzki. He’s a tremendous player and surely would be energized by moving to a winning environment. But it’s not just about the talent. It’s the age and money and injuries, too.

The Yankees and Mets would seem to be the best fits, and the Mets are especially interesting because they clearly have the young prospects to pull off such a deal. But while Mets management has been looking at the shortstop market for at least a year, they don’t seem willing to take on the risks that would come with Tulo.

The Yankees seem much more cautious about spending money too and probably have bigger needs in the rotation. Perhaps the only other team that makes sense would be the Padres, who’ve been baseball’s most aggressive club since general manager A.J. Preller came on board.

The Nationals might consider Tulowitzki with Ian Desmond in his walk year. The Nats also have enough young players to make such a deal work if general manager Mike Rizzo decides to shake things up. But like others, Rizzo covets his prospects and won’t deal them unless he’s convinced the deal would vault the Nationals deep into October.

At this point, no deal seems imminent. Even though certain general managers are starting to look their clubs less by the day, they don’t seem inclined to make the kind of commitment (money and prospects) Tulowitzki would require. Things can change quickly, so stay tuned.

Most interesting team in baseball? The Tampa Bay Rays might fit that description. As usual.

No team should feel better about itself than the Tampa Bay Rays, who are 1 1/2 games out of first place despite a huge roster overhaul and a ridiculous number of injuries. At 20-16, they’re four games above .500 for the first time this season after three straight victories over the Yankees.

Their pitching staff is among the best in baseball despite losing starters Alex Cobb and Drew Smyly for the season and not yet getting an inning out of Matt Moore. Meanwhile, their offense is a work in progress, which is another way of saying it hasn’t been very good. Still, as they survey the AL East landscape, the Rays have to be thinking, “Why not us?”

All of this comes after a tumultuous off-season in which two franchise cornerstones departed. President of Baseball Operations Andrew Friedman, who’d been instrumental in making the Rays one of the smartest and most efficient franchises in the game, took the same job with the Dodgers. And then Joe Maddon left to manage the Cubs.

Rays President Matt Silverman took over for Friedman and sprinted into the job by largely taking apart the roster and then putting it back together. When he was done, he was absolutely convinced that the Rays would be good enough to contend again.

They’ve been so consistently good through the years that we’ve come to take their success for granted. That’s perhaps the ultimate tribute to the organization owner Stuart Sternberg constructed. Much like Billy Beane in Oakland, the Rays have given every franchise a blueprint to succeed without spending huge amounts of money. There’s less margin for error, but the Rays are a reminder that smarts and competent people can make up for a lack of resources.

Since the beginning of the 2008 season, only the Yankees and Cardinals have won more regular-season games than the Rays. But the Rays have done it with a payroll that ranks 25th on average. This season, only the Astros and Diamondbacks have smaller payrolls than Tampa Bay’s $75 million.

To focus on what the Rays don’t have is to miss the larger point. They have plenty. First, they’ve got brains. Friedman departed, but his baseball operations staff remained largely intact, and Silverman had been involved at every level. And when he hired a new manager, he went for 37-year-old Kevin Cash, a former backup catcher known throughout the sport for his intelligence and people skills. At this point, it’s hard to see Silverman making a better hire.

And these Rays are pretty much like a lot of those other Rays teams. In Chris Archer, Jake Odorizzi and rookie Nate Karns at the top of a nice rotation, the Rays have a front three among the best in baseball. The Rays have already used eight starting pitchers and four rookies. They’ve sent five starting pitchers to the Disabled List six times. Yet their rotation leads the AL with a 3.48 ERA.

Resilience? The Rays have used 38 players, including 13 rookies, tops in the majors, according to Elias Sports Bureau. They have eight rookies on the roster at the moment. Seven players have made their Rays debut, including five who make their major league debut.

Tampa Bay’s bullpen is loaded with power arms, including closer Jake McGee, who was just activated after missing the first six weeks of the season recovering from elbow surgery.

(The Rays have allowed two runs or less 19 times, which is four more than any other team.)

What makes the Rays intriguing is that their young guys–outfielders Steven Souza and Kevin Kiermaier and starter Alex Colome–have a chance to get better as they become more comfortable in the big leagues. Rookies have hit 13 of their 31 home runs and started 15 of their 36 games.

While they may be far from a perfect team, there may not be one in the AL East. Like the Yankees, Tampa Bay’s strengths may more than offset its questionable areas. if they end up back in the playoffs, it would be the fifth time in eight seasons, which qualifies as sustained success. And if they do, it would be the sweetest one since 2008 when they shocked the baseball world by going from 96 losses to 97 victories and an American League pennant.

Mookie Betts is a rock star and other Opening Day takeaways

Opening Day delivered and so do I…

  •    Mookie Betts is a rock star in Boston, and what’s better than an Opening Day home run to emphasize that? He wasn’t even on the Red Sox radar a year ago. At one point, reporters asked John Farrell, “Why not bring this kid Betts up? He’s tearing it up at Pawtucket.” Soon after, he was up. He had to outplay Rusney Castillo to win a spot on the Opening Day roster, and he did that.
  • Clay Buchholz gave the Red Sox seven nice innings, and perhaps there’s no single piece of news that impacts a contender more than this one. If Clay Buchholz finally is the ace he has shown flashes of being when he’s healthy, the Red Sox are in a nice play.
  • Did you check out the times of games? Eight of the 14 games were played in well under 3 hours, six of them in 2:36 or faster. The basic commonsense changes may end up having a huge impact. Either that, or it was all those aces pitching on Opening Day.
  • Ben Zobrist played left field for the A’s, Eric Sogard moved back in at second and Sam Fuld played center. Sonny Gray pitched a great game, and the 2015 A’s start off on the right foot. This team may just hang with the Angels and Mariners all summer long. They’ve got 10 major league-ready starting pitchers, something no other team can say.
  • Orioles GM Dan Duquette makes an under-the-radar move to get Travis Snider to replace Nick Markakis in the right field. Snider gets three hits to help the O’s start with a win at Tampa Bay. This Duquette guy is good at his job.
  • Jimmy Rollins is not done.
  • Mike Moustakas is important to the Royals, both in production and in continuing the momentum of 2014. He’s off to a good start and so are the Royals.
  • David Price and Anibal Sanchez have to be great to keep the Tigers in the mix in the AL Central. Price started with a great performance.
  • Did you see Joey Votto and David Wright were hitting second? Someone is studying their analytics.

Parity? Competitive balance? I’m glad you ask.

Baseball’s competitive landscape has changed so much in recent years that it’s hard to grasp it all. It’s a new day, friends. Payroll no longer determines a team’s ability to compete. Smarts count, too. Big time.

So here’s to an Opening Day in which at least 25 of 30 teams believe they’re capable of going to the postseason. It has never been like this before.

Bud Selig had this crazy dream when he took over as commissioner 23 years ago. He believed the sport had to even the playing field and give more teams a chance to compete.

To that end, he commissioner a panel of economists and assorted other smart people to examine the sport. Selig laughs still when he remembers the day Paul Volcker, former Fed chairman, walked into his office.

“Big guy,” Selig said. “Cigar smoker. Brilliant. Intimidating.”


“He looks at me and says, `You have a problem,'” Selig remembered.

“Yeah, I know,” Selig told him. “That’s why you’re here.”

“You’ve got a system in which only about five teams are capable of winning,” Volcker said.

From this panel came change.

Revenue flowed from the larger-market teams to the smaller-market ones. A slotting system changed the draft. Also, about this time Billy Beane showed the world that there might be a better way of constructing a roster, one in which money wasn’t the deciding factor.

Little of this, little of that…

Here’s the bottom line:

  • 13 of 30 teams have played at least one postseason series the last two years.
  • 20 of 30 teams have played at least one the last five seasons.
  • Six different franchises have won the American League the last seven years.
  • Eight franchises have won the World Series the last 14 years.
  • The average payroll rank of the last 10 World Series winners is eighth.
  • In that time, the No. 1 payroll team has won just once–2009 Yankees
  • In 2014, 3 of the top 5 payroll teams and 6 of top 11 missed postseason.

Check out what Russell Martin said about his former skipper, Clint Hurdle

“He’s a great motivator. One thing I appreciate from Clint is that he’s always positive. Whether you’re sky high or grinding through a couple of losses, he always has the same attitude, the same presence. He creates that stability within the clubhouse. You know what to expect from him each and everyday. That’s comforting, especially for a younger clubhouse. That’s huge.”

Russell Martin on Clint Hurdle


No Darvish? So is there still a path to the postseason for the Rangers? As a matter of fact, there is.

This is a lousy break for the Texas Rangers. Let’s begin by acknowledging that much. No use sugarcoating it. In terms of pure stuff, Yu Darvish is right there with any pitcher in the game.

His 2013 season was Darvish at his best: 32 starts, 209.2 innings, 277 strikeouts and a 2.83 ERA. The Rangers figured he was capable of putting those numbers on the board again in 2015.

They’re a team of unknowns, especially regarding the health of some of their core players. With Prince Fielder, Shin Soo-Choo and Darvish all healthy, the Rangers have a chance to win 90-plus games. Without one of them, the math changes.

Amid reports that Darvish may undergo Tommy John surgery, the Rangers will once more be dipping into the pitching depth GM Jon Daniels has accumulated. That depth–in fact the overall minor league talent–was a reason to believe the Rangers could sustain success in the years ahead.

Now, though, they’re going to need some of that pitching depth in 2015. If you’re wondering why the Rangers don’t make a play for Cole Hamels, that’s an easy one. This isn’t the time.

The Rangers are one of the few franchises that have the young pitching depth to make a deal, but until Daniels has a better handle on his team, there’s no point in making a go-for-it deal.

Instead, the Rangers need to get a better gauge of what they already have.  The Rangers are in good shape in terms of veteran depth: Derek Holland, Yovani Gallardo, Colby Lewis and Ross Detwiler.

That’s a much more imposing growth when you put Darvish’s 220 innings up near the top of the group. Without him, it’s missing a bunch of quality innings.

Here’s where it gets interesting. Behind that group are younger pitchers like Nick Tepesch, Nick Martinez and Anthony Ranaudo. At various times, all of them have been high-ceiling prospects.

Even more interesting are the kids behind that group: Luke Jackson and Alex Gonzalez and Jake Thompson. Daniels was hoping that all of them would get important developmental innings in the minor leagues this season. Now the timetable could look a bit different.

The larger point is that the Rangers can still be in the conversation in an AL West that looks difficult. One of the things Daniels has done better than almost any other GM is built tremendous depth in the system.

Last season revealed holes in the upper parts of the system, but when the Rangers fast-tracked some of their kids, they passed every test and seem poised to contribute at some point in the not-too-distant future.

Kids don’t come with guarantees. Kids can disappoint. Kids can also do amazing things. Teams counting on young players–for instance, Tampa Bay–aren’t going to be favorites because of the unknown factor.

The Rangers weren’t going to be a playoff favorite even with Darvish at his best. They don’t appear to be as good as the Angels and Mariners and probably aren’t as good as the A’s.

Now they’ve got to recalibrate things again. Some of those kids may be called on sooner than expected. But the Rangers are more prepared to absorb an injury like this one than most other clubs.

Matt Harvey hits 99 mph and looked like his usual dominant self

“Things felt so good that the fact that I did have surgery was completely out of my mind.”

–Matt Harvey

It began with a sweet, sweet scene out in the bullpen before the game. As Matt Harvey warmed up, the Mets pitching staff gathered behind him, and when he was done, they surrounded him for a brief prep rally/welcome back moment.

And then he was off and running.

He touched 99 mph and was consistently in the 96-98 mph range with his fastball. He threw a couple of nasty curveballs. And he needed just 25 pitches to finish his two perfect innings. He struck out four, including one on a curve.

“The big thing was throwing strikes and not walking anyone,” Harvey said. “Those are the things you try and work on, especially hearing things about guys going through this process. Tough command.  That was the big thing I was focusing on and pretty happy about it.”

The Mets still have worries about Harvey, beginning with how his right elbow holds up in the wake of Tommy John surgery and missing the entire 2013 season. They worry that he’ll overdo it, so they’re slowing him down as much as possible.

On the other hand, he’s special. He’s always going to be different. He’s got that personality, too. He’s always going to be in the middle of things. Afterwards, he admitted he’d missed it all terribly.

“It was tough,” he told SNY. “I love being out there. not being able to do that was very tough at times.”

This was his first game in 560 days. It was a first step, nothing more. It’ll be weeks and weeks before we know for sure if Matt Harvey is back on his previous career path.

When we last saw him–on August 24, 2013–he was one of the two or three best pitchers in baseball. Let’s review:

  • He was No. 1 in FIP in 2013 at 2.00. That’s one of the purest ways to evaluate a pitcher apart from the circumstances that impact so many of his numbers.
  • He was No. 2 in WHIP at 0.93, trailing on Clayton Kershaw (0.92).
  • He was third with a 6.16 K/BB ratio.

Now for the good stuff:

  • His fastball was No. 1 in the majors at 95.8 mph, according to
  • His slider was No. 1 at 89.9 mph.
  • His curveball was No. 1 at 83.5 mph.

We love the art of pitching. We love someone’s ability to throw strikes and change speeds and to keep hitters off balance. But there’s nothing as compelling as a guy who throws the hell out of the baseball.

That’s the guy who challenges hitters, who is unafraid to make it me versus you. There’s a swagger to those kinds of guys. And that’s the other interesting part about Matt Harvey.

He carries himself in a way that may make him the most interesting athlete in New York if he can stay on the field. He’s not just good. He knows he’s good.

He carries himself like a star, and so this summer every single start he makes at Citi Field is going to be an event. We have to walk when he steps onto the mound because there just might be something we’ve never seen before.

Guys like Matt Harvey are good for the game. He may annoy the Mets at times with his swagger, but as Tony La Russa once said, “All the great ones are just a little bit different.”

The Mets are so optimistic that they’re good enough to contend again. They’ve got young pitching stacked up and a healthy David Wright and a packed farm system.

And if Harvey is healthy and if he’s at the front of that rotation, the Mets could end up being can’t miss television. And so on Friday afternoon, Matt Harvey made a meaningless exhibition game anything but.

A-Rod experiment rolls on.

“I’m just excited to be playing baseball again. It’s going to take two or three weeks for me to kind of get a gauge of where I am.” 

_ Alex Rodriguez

In the end, that’s all that matters. Can Alex Rodriguez still play? Can he help the Yankees win? When we last saw him in 2013, he looked like a guy with nothing left in the tank.

There’ll always a circus aspect to his presence, and there’s nothing he can do about that. But the Yankees have so much professional in their clubhouse that it’s not going to matter.

As Yankees manager Joe Girardi said on the first day of Spring Training, dealing with flurries of news and potential distractions is part of the experience.

A-Rod passed his first test earlier this week when he got a two-strike single in his first at-bat and drew a walk. But we really won’t know for weeks, as we figure out if his body will hold up and if he can still be a productive big league player.

“You just want to see his at-bats as he goes on, that he feels more comfortable,” Girardi said. “That he sees pitches. I don’t make too much out of players’ at-bats the first couple of weeks because they’re just getting back into it. I’ve said all along we’re going to wait to judge Alex. It’s not fair. He hasn’t played in two years.

“At-bats aren’t easy for a lot of guys this time of the year. Trying to get your timing. Guys are changing speeds. Sometimes, they’re command isn’t as great, and at-bats can be uncomfortable.”

He’s working at both first base and third base, but it’s unclear when he’ll play the field. If he has a role on the 2015 Yankees, it’s as a Designated Hitter.

Here’s what A-Rod had to say earlier this week…

  • “We want to get as many at-bats as possible. Yet, we don’t want to rush it.”
  • “It’s going to take time. I think two or three weeks from now I’ll have a much better idea. Right now, it’s about getting into playing shape.”
  • “Yeah, I was a little nervous. It’s been a long time since I put on the pinstripes. It’s definitely fun to have ‘em back on.”
  • “For me, the most incredible thing has been all the good-luck texts, emails and good wishes I’ve had from so many people. I never dreamed I’d get this kind of support. That part of it has been humbling.”
  • “Once you hit rock bottom, anytime you hear a few cheers these days is a pleasant surprise. That makes it better.”
  • “I love the game, and I’v been away from it for a long time. But it’s great to be back and have a bat in my mind.”
  • “I’m having fun. This is as much fun as I’ve had in a long time in Spring Training. Just feeling really grateful that I get to play the game that I love.”

In praise of the St. Louis Cardinals

They do things right. That’s not just winning baseball game, either. Obviously, that’s where it starts. In the last four seasons, the Cardinals have won 396 of those, postseason included. That’s 13 more than any other team in baseball, 29 more than any other National League team.

In the last 15 seasons, the Cardinals have been to the postseason 11 times. In that time, they’ve won six division championships, four NL pennants and two World Series. When the Cardinals and Giants played in the NLCS for the second time in three years last fall, it was a matchup of two franchises that might be the gold standard for all of baseball.

In terms of the ballpark experience and community involvement and creativity and innovation, the Cardinals take a backseat to no franchise in professional sports. That attitude begins with the owner, Bill DeWitt, Jr., but it permeates an entire organization. That’s why so many players will tell you their years with the Cardinals were the best of their career.

Is there a burden? Yes, there is. Players are held accountable by the media. And the St. Louis media has a high standard. That’s a result of the Cardinals having set the bar so high. If you’re a player or a manager, you have to be able to shut out the noise and do your job.

The Cardinals are again favored to win the NL Central. That would be their third straight and give them five straight seasons in the playoffs. They’re not without questions, especially among young players like Matt Adams and Kolten Wong. Michael Wacha and Jaime Garcia are recovering from injuries. Is there enough offense? Is the bullpen stable enough?

On the other hand, the Cardinals have fewer questions than any other NL Central team. The Cubs are a hot pick because of all those kids. The Reds could be very good if they get their main guys back on the field. The Pirates are good enough to make a third straight playoff appearance.

So nothing is guaranteed. But with another Spring Training here, the Cardinals are as usual one of the organizations every other will be measured against.

To understand baseball’s competitive balance, the American League is a good place to start.

There isn’t one clear favorite in the three American League divisions. Better yet, at least 13 of the 15 AL teams view making the playoffs as a reasonable goal for 2015.

This is the place to come to better understand baseball’s new competitive balance landscape. Expectations abound.

Let’s begin in the American League East. The Red Sox will begin Spring Training favored to make another worst-to-first run.

There’s also a case to be made for the Blue Jays and Rays. Only a knucklehead would count out the Orioles. As for that other AL East team…

The Yankees believe that landscape marked the end of a significant drought for their player development system with Dellin Betances, David Phelps, Shane Greene, Vidal Nuno, Adam Warren and Chase Whitley all contributing. Michael Pineda deserves to be on this list as well since he was acquired for Jesus Montero, then the pride of the Yankee farm system.

There’s more on the way: second baseman Rob Refsnyder, left-hander Jacob Lindgren, right-hander Jose Ramirez and outfielders Mason Williams, Tyler Austin and Ramon Flores.

Nothing is guaranteed, but this is a longer list of potentially big league-ready prospects than the Yankees have had awhile. And the point is a reminder that while the Yankees might be a logical pick for third, fourth or fifth in the AL East, it would be a huge mistake to overlook them.

The Tigers will be favored in the AL Central, but the Indians, Royals and White Sox are good enough to win. The Mariners and Angels may have separated themselves from the rest of the pack in the AL West, but the Rangers believe if they get a healthy and productive season from Prince Fielder, they’ve got a chance to be as good as any team in baseball.

And this is a reminder that it’s never been like this before in baseball. At least 24 teams have realistic expectations of getting to the postseason.

Last September 1st, 17 of baseball’s 30 teams were within 5 1/2 games of a postseason berth. In the last five seasons, 20 of 30 teams have played at least one postseason series, and 12 different franchises have been to the World Series the last 10 seasons.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 102 other followers